Special Offer: Get free Stashnote stickers with every order!

10% OFF with code “WelcomeCWnew”

CacheWerk - Your Geocaching & Outdoor Shop

Free shipping on orders over €25! (EU only)

Magnetic jar demagnetized? Here’s how to find the real cause

Magnetdose entmagnetisiert? So findest du die echte Ursache - CacheWerk

Does your magnetic container suddenly slip from the guardrail or fall out when you log? In most cases, it hasn't actually demagnetized. Much more often, rust, dirt, cracked rubber coating, loose adhesive, or a difficult surface are to blame. All of this creates a small gap between the magnet and the steel, and that gap is exactly what costs holding power. If the magnet itself has really lost its strength, remagnetizing it at home won't help: a new magnet or a new magnetic container designed for outdoor use is the faster and safer solution. At CacheWerk, you'll find magnetic nano-hides, magnetic containers, and spare parts developed by active geocachers and tested for outdoor use.

Cachewerk
Find a suitable magnetic hide
Discover magnetic nano-hides, magnetic containers, and spare parts for outdoor geocaches at CacheWerk.
Visit

Key Findings

  • True demagnetization is rare. It is usually caused by an air gap, dirt, rust, thin or non-magnetic surfaces, or a shifted magnet.
  • The countertest clarifies it in minutes: If the magnet holds firmly to a thick, bare steel surface, it is fine, and the problem lies with the location or the container.
  • Rust, cracks, and overheating are final. Such losses cannot be reversed by remagnetizing.
  • Remagnetizing with a different magnet does not work for neodymium and ferrite. This requires industrial equipment; a replacement is almost always cheaper.
  • New rubber coating only helps with intact magnets. It must be thin, UV-resistant, and airtight.

Table of Contents

Is your magnetic container really demagnetized? The 5-minute check

Before you replace magnets or touch any adhesive, find out where the problem really lies. This check works directly during maintenance, with a tissue and a pocket knife:

  1. Examine the magnet. Do you see brown rust blooms, peeling coating, cracks, or chipped corners? Then the magnet itself is damaged. This is the only case where you know immediately: It has to go.
  2. Check the fit. Does the magnet wobble, sit crooked, or sit deeper in the lid than before? Hot glue becomes brittle in frost and detaches. Even one millimeter more distance from the contact surface turns a firm hold into a slip.
  3. Clean the contact surface. Dirt, leaves, sand, ice, or paint chips between the magnet and steel act as spacers. Wipe it off once, reposition it, and feel the difference.
  4. Countertest on thick steel. Place the container on a thick, bare steel surface, such as a vise, a steel beam, or a solid workbench top, and pull it off vertically. If it holds firmly there, the magnet is healthy.
  5. Check the location. If the container holds firmly at home but not at the cache, the problem lies with the surface: thin sheet metal, thick paint, plastic film, aluminum, or stainless steel. Many traffic signs are made of aluminum, and many types of stainless steel barely attract magnets.

You can find a detailed troubleshooting guide covering all location pitfalls in our post Magnetic container does not hold: Causes and solutions.

The most common causes at the cache location

If a magnetic container is struggling, one of these causes is usually behind it. The table helps you get from the symptom to the solution:

What you observe Probable cause What helps
Holds firmly at home, not at the cache Thin sheet metal, thick paint, aluminum, or stainless steel Choose another spot on the object or use a stronger magnet
Holds less firmly than in summer Ice, dirt, or leaves on the contact surface Clean, place the container dry during maintenance
Magnet wobbles or sits crooked Adhesive has come loose, magnet has shifted Reattach the magnet, screw it in better, or encase it
Rust under the rubber coating Coating damaged, moisture penetrated Replace the magnet, rubber coating alone is not enough
Cracks or chipped corners Fall, impact, frost Replace the magnet or container
Slips sideways, but holds vertically Sideways hold is significantly weaker than the vertical pull Position the container so that it hangs instead of sticking sideways, use a second magnet
Holds less firmly after painting Paint on the magnet side creates a gap Leave the magnet side bare or tape it off

This is especially true when camouflaging, as the last point happens quickly. How to paint without sacrificing holding power is explained in our post Painting a magnetic container and preserving camouflage.

Why is the sideways hold so much weaker? The stated holding power of a magnet refers to pulling it vertically off a thick, smooth steel plate without any gap. However, at a vertical guardrail, gravity pulls sideways on the container. Then only friction holds, and that is considerably smaller. A container that holds loosely in a test can therefore still slip at the actual location, even if nothing has demagnetized.

When a magnet really loses strength

A permanent magnet does not consume energy when holding. It also does not get weaker because cachers take it off and put it back a hundred times. Real loss of strength has concrete triggers:

  • Heat: Standard-quality neodymium magnets are heat-sensitive. A hot-air gun, soldering iron, hot glue gun directly on the magnet, or a black power box in the blazing sun will damage them.
  • Strong opposing fields: If several strong magnets are placed incorrectly next to each other, or if the container sticks to another powerful magnet for a long time, this can weaken the magnetization.
  • Rust: If the coating cracks, a neodymium magnet will rust. The rusty material is no longer magnetic, so the magnet effectively gets smaller.
  • Breakage: Neodymium is hard but brittle. A fall on asphalt or a hammer blow can chip off corners or create cracks.

Experts distinguish three types of loss. A white paper by Arnold Magnetic Technologies on magnetization losses describes them as follows: Reversible losses due to temperature disappear again as soon as the magnet cools down. Irreversible losses due to heat or an opposing field remain, but can be remedied by remagnetizing. Permanent losses due to chemical changes or material loss through corrosion, on the other hand, are final.

For you as an owner, this means: If your container holds less firmly on a hot summer day and normally again in the evening, everything is fine. If the magnet is rusty or chipped, however, replacement is the only option.

Can you remagnetize a magnet?

The short answer: theoretically yes, practically no for geocachers.

You may know the small magnetizers for screwdrivers. They work because tool steel is magnetically soft and can be aligned by a weak field. Neodymium and ferrite magnets, on the other hand, are magnetically hard. That is exactly what makes them so strong and permanent, and that is exactly why remagnetizing requires a field that is far stronger than anything another permanent magnet can deliver.

As a rule of thumb for remagnetization, hard ferrite requires triple the coercive force. The coercive force describes how strong an opposing field must be to demagnetize the magnet. For parts that were demagnetized in alternating fields, even considerably higher field strengths are required than for the initial magnetization. Such fields are generated by industrial magnetizing devices with a coil and a powerful current pulse.

What this means for you:

  • Rubbing with another magnet will not bring a weak neodymium magnet back.
  • Self-made coils on a wall socket or car battery are dangerous and do not reach the necessary field strength. Stay away from them.
  • Rusty, broken, or overheated magnets will not become properly good again even in a professional device, because the material itself has been altered.

A small magnet in a geocache container is so inexpensive that a replacement is always the better choice.

Renewing the rubber coating of the magnetic container

The rubber coating is the protective shell of your magnet. It keeps moisture away from the neodymium, protects the paint on the object, provides friction against sideways slipping, and dampens impacts. If it becomes cracked, water reaches the magnet and rust begins. That is why renewing it is worth it as long as the magnet underneath is still bare and undamaged.

The cracked rubber coating reveals the rusty magnet

The right material for outdoors

For a cache that hangs outside in the sun, rain, and frost all year round, UV resistance is especially important. A comparison of magnet coatings recommends EPDM with an operating range of −40 to +130 °C or silicone from −60 to +200 °C for outdoor use. Nitrile rubber (NBR), on the other hand, is described as UV-sensitive: It cracks in the sun within one to two years. A pure epoxy layer, on the other hand, is considered suitable only for dry indoor spaces.

So pay attention to these points when choosing a material:

  • UV- and weather-resistant, expressly for outdoor use
  • Thinly applicable, because every layer is also distance from the steel
  • Processable without heat, so the magnet does not suffer
  • Adheres well to metal, so no moisture creeps under the edge

Step by step

  1. Remove the old rubber coating. Cut it off carefully with a utility knife and pull it off. Place the knife flat so that you do not scratch the nickel layer of the magnet. This is where most mistakes happen: A scratch in the coating is the next breeding ground for rust.
  2. Examine the magnet. If it is bare and intact, you can continue. If you see rust, bubbles, or cracks, stop here and replace the magnet. A new rubber coating over rust will only trap the moisture.
  3. Clean and degrease. Wipe the magnet with isopropanol and let it dry completely. Grease and fingerprints prevent the new layer from adhering.
  4. Apply thinly. Apply liquid rubber in several thin layers and let each layer dry according to the manufacturer's instructions. Three thin layers are better than one thick one: The contact side should be protected, but remain as thin as possible.
  5. Seal the edges. The transition between the magnet and the container is the weak point. Pull the rubber coating slightly over the edge so that no water runs under the layer.
  6. Let dry without a heat gun. Patience instead of hot air. Heat does speed up drying, but it can damage a neodymium magnet.

If the magnet sits loosely, this is the moment to reattach it permanently. How to do this weatherproofly is explained in our post Attaching a neodymium petling magnet weatherproofly. If you place two magnets next to each other, check the polarity of the magnets beforehand so that they do not push each other out of place.

Afterward: Check hold and protection

Before the container goes back to the cache, test it in two steps:

  • Pull vertically on a thick, bare steel surface. If it holds firmly, the new layer is not too thick.
  • Test at the actual location, i.e., sideways on the guardrail or upside down under the railing. Shake it lightly, just as a cacher would when searching. If it slips, choose a more favorable spot or a stronger magnet.

Also look at the rubber coating during every maintenance, especially after winter and after a hot summer. Fine cracks at the edge are the first warning signal.

Replace instead of repairing: When the new container is better

Repairing is fun and sometimes saves a trip to the mailbox. But there are clear cases in which a new container or a new magnet is the better choice:

  • The magnet is rusty, cracked, or chipped.
  • The magnet was too weak from the start for the location. Then every repair only repeats the old problem.
  • The container itself is not airtight, the logbook is damp, the lid no longer closes.
  • The magnet was only glued and has already come loose several times.
  • You have several logs saying "container was on the ground" or a Needs-Maintenance report, i.e., a hint from a finder that your cache needs maintenance.

The glued magnet is a classic. Why we prefer screwed or encased solutions and how to prevent rust from the start is explained in the post Stopping rust on the magnetic container. And if you are considering switching to a flat solution: Our comparison Magnetic foil or neodymium magnet helps you with the choice.

New magnetic hides from CacheWerk

When your old container is empty, it's worth starting fresh with a hide designed for exactly this purpose. Our hides are developed, tested, and optimized for outdoor use by active geocachers, many of them 3D-printed from PETG.

Geocaching Hide | Screw with Secret Compartment & Magnet | 2 Pieces | Nano Cache | CacheWerk

For magnetic nanos, we have, for example:

You can find weather-resistant logbooks, spare parts, and other accessories for owners in our Geocaching Equipment and Accessories category.

Our Perspective from Experience

If a magnetic container no longer holds, it's worth taking a first look at the magnet and its position, not at physics. As a rule, the magnet hasn't weakened, but has gained distance from the steel: due to rust, adhesive residue, dirt, or a coating that is too thick or cracked.

That's why we develop our hides as active geocachers, test them, and optimize them for outdoor use. A magnetic hide must hold in frost, rain, and summer heat at real locations, not just on a desk.

Our advice: Repair what is worth it, and replace what is damaged. A rusty magnet won't get better, and a cache that constantly lies on the ground brings joy neither to you nor to the finders. A new, well-thought-out hide is quickly placed, and then you have time again for what it's really about: placing and finding new caches.

Benedikt

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I recharge a neodymium magnet with another magnet?

No. Neodymium magnets are magnetically hard and need a field that no other permanent magnet can generate to be remagnetized. Only industrial devices with a strong electrical pulse can do this. For a geocache container, a new magnet is the easier solution.

Does a magnet get weaker if cachers take the container off often?

No. A permanent magnet does not consume energy when holding and does not wear out from being attached and detached. What suffers is rather the coating or the adhesive. Therefore, when maintaining, check above all the position and coating.

Why does my magnetic container hold worse in winter?

Usually, it is due to ice, dirt, or moisture between the magnet and the steel, which forms a gap. Hot glue also becomes brittle in the cold and can come loose. Clean the contact surface and check if the magnet is still firmly attached.

Does a magnetic container hold on stainless steel or aluminum?

No magnet holds on aluminum, and many types of stainless steel barely attract magnets. If your container does not hold on a sign or railing, test it on a thick steel surface. If it holds there, the problem is not the magnet, but the substrate.

Sources

Recommendations